Talk:Knob Goblin Harem Girl

From TheKolWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Hp (without level boost): 19 - 24


Era Date Encountered Knob Goblin perfume Knob Goblin harem veil harem girl t-shirt Knob Goblin harem pants disease finger cymbals Information Source
1 25-Mar-06 1236 295 88 36 61 N/A Item Drop Bonus: +50%
(with TA)
25-Mar-06 34 7 2 1 2 Item Drop Bonus: +30%
(with TA)
2 17-18 May 09 151 100 26 N/A 23 79 37 Item Drop Bonus: +343.4456%
(without TA)
504 301 102 43 81 205 81 Item Drop Bonus: +304.8715%
(with TA; wh: 45)
173 101 31 N/A 27 71 35 Item Drop Bonus: +303.4404%
(without TA)
163 91 23 5 23 54 47 Item Drop Bonus: +285.8714%
(with TA; wh: 45)
23 May 09 196 133 35 N/A 27 91 43 Item Drop Bonus: +348.4456%
(without TA)
Observed Rate
  • Added drop data collected after the finger cymbals drop was added. Shirt is 2%, Pants are 4%, veil is 5%, perfume is 15%, disease is 10%, cymbals are 5%. --Flargen 06:05, 18 May 2009 (UTC)
    • Since it was "unsatisfactory" that the veil and pants would have a slightly different rate, I've collected and added more data. They're both 4% now. Rest is as previously indicated. --Flargen 07:29, 23 May 2009 (UTC)


I dont think the swindleblossem drop rate is correct. I have a level 30 gravy fairy and had to fight 8 harem girls to get 3 swindleblossems. The level 30 fairy alone means the drop rate has to be less than 60%, correct? With that data, im going to change the drop rate to Approx. 30%. Though i calculate 21% from my data, i know im very unlucky when it comes to quest item drops. --Currman 12:37, 3 May 2007 (CDT)

  • You probably shouldn't make any changes until you have some more statistically significant numbers. Something along the lines of fighting 1000 harem girls. Talk to Yiab as statistics is his baby...he might even already have numbers on that. --Fryguy9 16:48, 3 May 2007 (CDT)
    • I'd agree with taking a second look at the swindleblossom rates (and the other Doc quest items); in the past eight ascencions I've made, it's taken me an average of forty-five of the appropriate kills to get all 9 herbs. Fifty percent drop rate is WAY off. --Liokae


Expect for the minor problem that 90% is completely impossible, if that were the drop rate, i would get one every time. I'll just change it to the maximum possible drop rate, 57.1%, which ill round to 60% for convienence. Though it breaks template "Less than 60%" would be more appropriate here. (but i dont break templates)

A 95% confidence interval on my sample size of 8 gives a upper bound of 52%. So, assuming RNG hates me(it does), ill change it to "Approx. 50%", which, reguardless of the true value, would be closer than "Approx. 90%."

In other news, the swindleblossom drop rate was not done by yiab, anyhow. The person who did it doesnt seem to realize that he should be using "Approx." when putting numbers in.

Clearly more data would be needed to get a precise drop rate, but, I beat the quest, so i cannot do that. --Currman 13:34, 9 May 2007 (CDT)

Just had one fail at +124% item drop, so it's definitely below 50%. --Psly4mne 18:34, 22 May 2010 (UTC)


My data set is too small to conclude this with certainty, but it appears this monster no longer drops the perfume, as of the Feb 2011 revamp. Needs spading. --Greycat 00:04, 16 February 2011 (UTC)

Yellow-rayed one with negative item drops (pith helmet for MP while I searched, scuba gear to cancel passives, no +item effects). It dropped: pants, veil, disease, cymbals. --Greycat 00:56, 16 February 2011 (UTC)

I just failed to get one from a major yellow ray. It was not pickpocketed prior. --Shademaster00 01:23, 17 February 2011 (UTC)